International Racing Form: Comparing Horses Across Countries
Pounds or kilos, furlongs or metres, OR, benchmarks or the HKJC scale: every country writes its form in its own units. How to read a horse that has raced in more than one of them.
Horses travel more than ever. Australian sprinters run at Royal Ascot, European stayers go for the Melbourne Cup, the Dubai World Cup Carnival brings runners from Britain, Ireland, Japan, South Africa and America to one track, and every horse in Hong Kong is an import. Each of them arrives with form written in a different language, and before you can compare it with the locals, you have to translate it. The translation is where most of the mistakes happen.
The same horse, written five ways
Each country prints weights, distances and official marks in its own units:
| Country | Weights | Distances | Official mark or class |
|---|---|---|---|
| Britain and Ireland | Stones and pounds | Miles and furlongs | Official Rating (OR), in pounds |
| Australia | Kilograms | Metres | Benchmark rating (BM) |
| Hong Kong | Pounds | Metres | HKJC rating |
| France | Kilograms | Metres | Valeur, a mark in kilos |
| Germany | Kilograms | Metres | GAG |
| Japan | Kilograms | Metres | Classes by wins: 1 Win, 2 Wins, 3 Wins, then Open, Listed and Group |
The units are the easy part, because they convert by arithmetic: a kilo is about 2.2 lb, there are 14 lb to the stone, and a furlong is about 201 metres, so 6f is about 1,200 m and a mile about 1,600 m.
The marks are the hard part. Each official scale is set by its own handicappers for its own racing, and none of them converts by formula into another. A 100 on one scale and a 100 on another are not the same horse.
The class label does not travel either
Class names look alike and mean different things. In Hong Kong, Class 5 is the bottom of the handicap ladder, yet on our scale the average Hong Kong Class 5 race sits around 110, above the 100 of a lower-grade handicapper elsewhere. The floor in Hong Kong is high because every horse is an import bought to race there, and a Hong Kong Class 3 race, in the mid-120s on our scale, is run at the level of a good Saturday handicap anywhere.
The same goes for Japan, where the classes are counted by wins rather than set by a handicap mark, and for France, where the valeur is given in kilos rather than pounds. Read the level the horse ran to, not the label on the race.
The going words don't line up
| Country | Going, from fastest to slowest |
|---|---|
| Britain and Ireland, turf | Hard, firm, good to firm, good, good to soft, soft, heavy (yielding in Ireland for good to soft) |
| Britain, all-weather | Fast, standard to fast, standard, standard to slow, slow |
| Australia | Firm 1-2, Good 3-4, Soft 5-7, Heavy 8-10 |
| Japan, turf | Firm, good to firm, good, yielding, soft |
| Japan, dirt | Standard, good, muddy, sloppy |
| USA, dirt | Fast, wet fast, good, muddy, sloppy, slow, sealed |
The same word does not always mean the same ground. The Japan Racing Association's own race cards note that its standard may differ from that of the country where a race was run. Our own data adds a warning about the words at home: tracks called heavy really did ride slow, but tracks called soft rode normal or faster most of the time. Believe the times before the label.
Programmes and biases differ too
Even with every run on one scale, the base rates are local. About 53.5% of Australian races are sprints, while about half of French races are run over 1,800 m or more. On Irish turf and Meydan dirt the lead is worth a lot, and on French all-weather it is worth almost nothing. Favourites win about 35% of races in Australia and about 27% in the UAE. A horse that has spent its career in one of those programmes has been answering a different question from the horses it meets abroad. How horse racing form differs by country goes through it country by country.
A method for a horse that has travelled
- Put the runs on one scale first. Until you can see the overseas runs and the local runs side by side in the same units, every comparison is a guess.
- Read what each run was. The surface, the going, the distance in the units you know, the class and the field size.
- Judge the horse on its best recent runs in conditions like today's, not on its last run, and not on its best run in conditions it won't meet today.
- Check the fit. An Australian sprinter used to racing around a turn meets something new on Ascot's straight six furlongs with its uphill finish, and a Meydan dirt horse switching to turf is starting from scratch on that surface.
- Be careful with the first run in a new country. A long trip, a new climate and a new routine are all part of that run, and one run is a small sample.
- Then price it, the same way you would price a local horse.
MWP rates the form the same way in every country it covers, so a run at Sha Tin and a run at Flemington sit on one scale and in one form table. Every performance gets a rating unless making one would be a guess, and you can hover any rating to read it on the official scale you know, OR, benchmark, HKJC, valeur, GAG or formtall, measured from real results rather than converted by a formula. Start with the international form guide, open a free sample racecard, or learn the method in our free course, Do Your Homework.
Related: How horse racing form differs by country · Ratings and speed figures explained · How to read a Hong Kong form guide · How to read an Australian form guide · UK form guide explained · International form guide